Emerald Fennell’s much-anticipated take on Wuthering Heights, starring Australian stars Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie, is dividing critics just days before its Valentine’s weekend release. The film reimagines Emily Brontë’s classic tale of obsession, revenge, and passion, centering on the intense relationship between Cathy and Heathcliff.
Critics Divided: Praise vs Criticism
The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw criticized the film as an “emotionally hollow, bodice-ripping misfire,” giving it just two stars. He described Fennell’s approach as over-the-top, calling it “a 20-page fashion shoot of relentless silliness,” complete with ripped bodices and hints of BDSM.
On the other hand, Robbie Collin of the Telegraph awarded it five stars, calling it “resplendently lurid, oozy, and wild.” Collin defended the film against claims of style over substance, arguing that Fennell proves style can enhance the story. According to him, Cathy and Heathcliff’s emotions shine through their clothing, settings, and every cinematic detail.
A Bold, Stylized Take
The film, set in the late 18th and early 19th century, stars Elordi, 28, and Robbie, 35, as the iconic lovers. Fennell markets it with quotation marks around the title, signaling her personal interpretation of Brontë’s novel. Adding to the film’s modern edge, pop singer Charli XCX created an original soundtrack.
Some critics, like Dulcie Pearce from the Sun, compared the film’s drama to a Mills & Boon romance, claiming it prioritizes sex over story. Clarisse Loughrey from the Independent was harsher, giving the film one star. She argued the adaptation pushed the lead performances toward pantomime while portraying the poor as sexual deviants and the wealthy as clueless.
Mixed But Memorable
Other reviewers offered more balanced takes. Danny Leigh of the Financial Times gave it three stars, describing the sexual tension as a mix of arthouse style and comedy reminiscent of a Carry On film. Similarly, Donald Clarke from the Irish Times praised the adaptation’s narrative structure, noting its surprising loyalty to Brontë’s original story. Empire’s Beth Webb also awarded three stars, calling it “undeniably expertly crafted” and highlighting Elordi’s rising star power, though she wished the film’s energy lasted throughout.
Conclusion
Fennell’s Wuthering Heights is a polarizing cinematic experiment. Some view it as a bold, stylish reinvention that captures the raw passion of Brontë’s characters, while others feel it sacrifices depth for visual flair. Audiences are likely to leave the theater either enthralled or underwhelmed.
