Alaska Senator Breaks With Party on Election Reform
Senator Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, announced she will not back new voter ID legislation, signaling a major break from GOP leadership and former President Donald Trump. She made the announcement on X, emphasizing that imposing stringent federal election rules now “is not how we build trust” in the democratic process.
Her stance highlights the political reality in the Senate: without dramatic measures like eliminating the filibuster or securing Democratic support, new federal voter ID laws have little chance of passing.
Criticism of SAVE America and MEGA Acts
Murkowski specifically criticized two proposals moving through Congress: the Safeguarding American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) Act and the Make Elections Great Again (MEGA) Act. Both bills would implement nationwide voter ID requirements and other election integrity measures backed by Trump and conservative senators.
“When Democrats tried sweeping election reforms in 2021, Republicans opposed them because they would federalize elections. Now, these bills would do effectively the same thing, and I cannot support them,” Murkowski explained.
The 2021 proposals — the John Lewis Voting Rights Act and the For the People Act — failed amid bipartisan opposition. Republicans argued they would centralize control of elections under the federal government, undermining state and local authority.
Federal Overreach vs. State Authority
Murkowski stressed that the Constitution grants states control over federal elections, including the “times, places, and manner” of voting.
“One-size-fits-all mandates from Washington rarely work, especially in Alaska,” she said. “Imposing new federal rules while states are already preparing for Election Day would force election officials to scramble, potentially harming election integrity.”
She added that public trust in elections is essential, and that federal overreach is not the way to secure it.
Political Implications for the GOP
Murkowski’s opposition comes as Trump and House Republicans push to nationalize elections via the SAVE America Act. Some Senate Republicans, including Majority Leader John Thune, have voiced concerns about federalizing elections, though few have publicly opposed the voter ID effort.
Given the 60-vote threshold required to overcome the Senate filibuster, passing the bill without Democratic cooperation is highly unlikely. In practical terms, Murkowski’s stance could signal the end of the effort.
“Ensuring public confidence in elections is the priority. Federal mandates are not the solution,” Murkowski concluded.
