AI Mock Up Sparks Artist Backlash
Glasgow street artist Rogue One has confirmed plans to paint a new mural, following criticism over the use of AI in its early design stage. Several artists raised concerns, arguing that human creativity should be involved from the very beginning.
However, Rogue One, whose real name is Bobby McNamara, said the mural remains at an early concept stage.
Why AI Was Used Initially
McNamara explained that he was approached about the project last year but did not have time to produce a design. As a result, Derek Paterson, owner of Balmoral Estates, submitted the proposal himself.
Paterson used AI to create a basic mock up so he could apply for planning permission and explore funding options.
McNamara said the AI image was never meant to be the final work. Instead, it was only used to start the process.
Final Design Will Be Human Made
The artist stressed that he will fully design and paint the mural himself if the project moves forward. He added that the finished artwork could look very different from the AI image.
McNamara said it will be several months before any painting begins.
Abuse and Wider Artist Concerns
Paterson previously said he received online abuse after the proposal became public.
Meanwhile, artists across Scotland voiced frustration about AI replacing paid creative work. Many fear it is already affecting livelihoods.
Artist Ashley Rawson described the use of AI as culturally damaging and driven by cost cutting rather than meaning.
Strong Reactions From Artists
Inverness-based artist Michael Forbes criticised the AI image, calling it soulless and confusing. He questioned its random elements, including a two headed eagle and unrelated symbols.
However, Forbes said he hopes the final mural will not resemble the mock up.
